Rise of Real

AI Vs The Creative Process: Where does it belong?

Claude could generate a script for a feature length film quicker than you can type all the lyrics to supercalifragilisticexpialidocious… both would be a waste of time.

Now, AI can churn out 100 ideas faster than Bolt runs the 100 metres*. But since when is 100 wrong ideas that don’t answer the brief better than 1 idea that does? I’m sure there’s some clever analogy I could write about shooting arrows on target, but I’ve chosen the human approach of basically saying it’s like throwing sh*t at the wall and seeing what sticks.

Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think AI making mistakes is actually the problem. It’s more the fact it can make the wrong answer look finished. Laminating it in an untouchable seal, removing the natural instinct to question it. Our confirmation bias will equate polish with quality, assuming the normal review process has happened to have reached this stage. But when AI has the ability to make everything look like ‘final_final_V2’ from the first draft, that’s where our human brains need to step in.

As an Art Director, it may be slightly controversial to say I do believe there’s a place for AI in the industry, but I think we need to embrace it as a tool rather than a replacement. When I asked Kaz, our Senior Designer, whether this shift felt similar to the big boom of Photoshop, her answer surprised me.

She said “no I don’t, strangely that always felt more like a tool to help, i.e. “look what you can do… with this program” not “look what this can do…”.

That’s where the distinction lies, because Photoshop was always sold as something for Creatives to be more creative, whereas AI lets anyone become a Creative. Which on the surface, sounds great, but AI could also let me become a finance bro, and I don’t think that would be good for anyone.

Which brings me on to the power of expertise. Let the designers design. Let the art directors direct. Let the copywriters write, and most importantly, let each expert decide how new technology will best support them.
So, with that in mind… to get a real picture from start to finish, I asked every step of our creative department. From concept through to artwork and every step in between to see the real uses and pitfalls of AI as we stand.

 

Where does AI belong in the creative process?

 

Concept

AI has been incredibly useful for generating scamps, combining multiple images into one franken-sketch has been a great example of time saving. Interestingly, the reverse can be true when we generated concept images that were almost too good that the client wanted those instead… hard lesson learned.

For writing, it can be great for idioms, sayings, discovering links between topics and giving a starting point, however it struggles to show anything out of the ordinary. Which might pose an interesting benchmark for concepts? As our Creative Director Olivia Downing says, “Often those really fantastic creative ideas are when someone says something when you’re chatting about the brief that’s totally left field and unrelated.” 

 

Design

The dawn of the ‘AI flyer’ is well and truly nigh, and I think we’re already experiencing this allergic reaction from buyers. In my research I discovered that in some cases, people associate this quick turnaround, low effort marketing to be a reflection of the quality and standards of the business.

The consensus with designers was that it’s yet to produce something they would be proud to have made themselves. The most useful tool seemed to be image expansion and generative fill; designers would also use AI to create prompts which I think is a great use of its abilities. However, as our Head of Design, Liv Holder put it “AI can take too much creative liberty, adding unintended elements or straying from the original ask, with results often feeling like a total roulette”. I found that idea of gambling quite an interesting analogy, which segues perfectly to motion.

 

Motion

Our Motion Designer, Emma, told me a story of another agency, where the client wanted a completely AI video. The client also happened to have… very high standards. Which meant with every round of feedback came another hefty cost of credits. Literally gambling real money with every generation. Not knowing if it will produce what was expected. On the other hand, we have also had great success with AI turning inanimate objects into film, especially with tight deadlines it has proved useful.

 

Repro

Similarly to design, repro praised AI for image extension and generative fill, these elements especially have come on massively in the last couple of years. Originally, AI was shunned for its print quality, but as it develops and we find new ways to combine tools, we’ve proven it’s possible to generate high-quality imagery suitable for print. Although from experience, we know it’s always worth having a check over (for anyone that remembers the burnt-out car in the Thames…).

Our Senior Retoucher, Gee, explained how it has been very beneficial for the smaller, repetitive tasks like updating a presentation with the latest round of amends. Giving her actual time back to do the job that requires a human eye. As one of our AI testers, she has been looking at interesting ways the business could use it on the whole but did say “on a personal note as a retoucher I can’t say its massively changed the game for me (YET)”

 

Artwork

The most helpful use of AI for artwork has been assisting with time consuming tasks like proof-reading large documents, checking grammar and spelling, and cross-referencing dates. Our Deputy Studio Manager, Paul Tomlin, confirmed this has been a genuine time-saver in the department. It’s also been very handy for turning designing assets into mock-ups or WAGLLS (waj-juls – meaning: What A Good Job Looks Like) as we like to call it.

 

Finding the balance

I think it’s safe to say that AI is in all our processes and it is going nowhere soon. As our Studio Manager, Neil puts it “The future will be how AI becomes a trusted part of all of our current applications and processes without losing that ability we have to question and push an idea forward”

 

An interesting consensus is that most areas have been more impressed by AI when it does the things they don’t usually do in their day-to-day, for example a designer is impressed with AI copy, or repro is more pleased with an AI video. But when asking people if AI could do their own job, the answers are far less favourable.

 

It’s incredible how much this technology has advanced in just a few years. I’m sure it will get equally impressive and terrifying as the years go on. One thing we all agree on is it’s moving so fast, with new plug-ins and options coming every day, so who knows, after the next big update this could all be irrelevant.

But right now, relying on AI to become a Creative is inevitably a false efficiency, we’ve been sold the world of quicker, more time back, take the pressure off, but sometimes fixing the problems for an immovable deadline will have you working harder than a one-legged man in an ass-kicking competition.

So, in my humble, long-winded opinion, I believe creative judgment is best left to our experts, and the need for speed is best left to Top Gun.

 

*I asked ChatGPT for 100 headlines ideas for an article on AI, it took 8.2s, compared to Bolt’s current World Record is 9.58s. How’s that for primary research?

By Sophie Stevens, Art Director, CreativeRace